Bathtubs take a lot of wear and tear over the years. The finish dulls, small chips appear, or the surface begins to peel. When that happens, property managers and homeowners are often left wondering: should you resurface, strip, or replace? Knowing the difference helps make the right call for both budget and long-term durability.

When Resurfacing Makes Sense

Resurfacing (also called refinishing or reglazing) is a great option when the tub itself is still structurally sound but just looks tired. If the issue is cosmetic (dullness, minor stains, or small chips) resurfacing restores the tub’s color and sheen and makes it look nearly new again. It’s affordable and done in just a day, which makes it a practical choice when time and budget matter.

When Stripping Becomes Necessary

Stripping comes into play when the tub has already been resurfaced in the past. Over time, those coatings eventually wear down or start to peel. In some cases, multiple layers of resurfacing build up, and a new coat won’t bond properly. Stripping removes the old finish entirely so the next resurfacing can adhere the way it should, ensuring a clean, long-lasting result.

When Replacement Is the Only Responsible Choice

There are situations where resurfacing just isn’t enough. If the tub has cracks, leaks, rust damage, or other structural problems, replacement is the only safe option. The same applies when hidden issues in the walls or subfloor show up during inspection, or when a remodel calls for a different style or layout altogether. In those cases, a new tub is the best long-term investment.

Bottom Line

Resurfacing is an affordable way to extend a tub’s life, stripping ensures lasting adhesion, and replacement is the right call when safety or structure is at risk. The right choice depends on condition, budget, and long-term goals. That being said, making the honest choice up front always saves more down the line.